Plans for Return Hubs in Rwanda Are Controversial

Germany and four other European countries have a plan: They want to deport rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda in East Africa as early as 2027. The individuals must be subject to a departure order, and their countries of origin must refuse to readmit them. This plan by the EU countries is controversial. Public criticism is currently coming from politicians in the Green Party, the Left Party, and the SPD, as well as from human rights activists, human rights organizations, and religious groups.

Most of those required to leave the country have temporary residence permits

As of the end of September 2026, there were approximately 257,000 people living in Germany who are required to leave the country. However, according to the Mediendienst Integration, around 61 percent of them are rejected asylum seekers. Around 78 percent of those required to leave have a temporary stay permit and cannot be deported. This applies to around 200,000 people. This means that approximately 56,300 people in Germany would be affected by the EU countries’ plan. So far, the plan calls for the creation of about 100 spots in a “return hub” in Rwanda.

The Ministry of the Interior sees “a new opportunity”

In addition to Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece, and the Netherlands are exploring with Rwanda the “possible establishment of a return hub,” according to the Federal Ministry of the Interior in Berlin. The ministry states that this model offers those affected “a new opportunity”: to integrate into Rwandan society, to leave Rwanda voluntarily, or to travel to their country of origin or another country where they are permitted to enter legally.

Concerns About Human Rights in Rwanda

In the ministry’s statement, Rwanda is described as a “reliable and responsible partner” in the context of migration and displacement. There are doubts about this. Volker Türk, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, identified “human rights risks.” Amnesty International (AI) is urging the German government to “withdraw from the agreement.” The human rights organization points to failed projects by other countries, such as the U.S. and Italy, and the problematic human rights situation in Rwanda. “What remains is human suffering and a policy that turns people seeking protection into objects of deterrence,” said Julia Duchrow, Secretary General of AI.

46 European organizations warn of a “disaster”

Pro Asyl and a European coalition of 45 organizations oppose the planned “deportation deal.” It is “a human disaster waiting to happen,” said Karl Kopp, executive director of Pro Asyl. One argument: Rwanda does not meet the minimum requirements of international human rights standards. They cite political tensions, torture, support for a violent rebel group in the Eastern Congo conflict, and serious war crimes committed by Rwandan armed forces on Congolese territory. In 2023, the UK Supreme Court halted deportations to Rwanda due to the risks involved.

A Plea for a Solidarity-Based Asylum System

https://mediendienst-integration.de/fluechtlinge/abschiebungen/wie-viele-personen-sind-ausreisepflichtig/
On the Ministry of the Interior:
https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/pressemitteilungen/DE/2026/11/return-hubs-ruanda.html
On human rights issues:
https://unric.org/de/un-menschenrechtskommissar-tuerk-sieht-plaene-von-eu-laendern-fuer-abschiebezentren-in-ruanda-mit-sorge/
https://www.amnesty.de/pressemitteilung/ruanda-abschiebungszentren-abkommen
https://www.proasyl.de/pressemitteilung/pro-asyl-zum-deal-mit-ruanda-menschenrechtliches-desaster-mit-ansage/
https://www.kirche-und-leben.de/artikel/flucht-migration-return-hubs-rueckkehrzentren-ruanda-afrika-bundesinnenminister-alexander-dobrindt-plaene-kritik-kirchen-bischoefe-stephan-ackermann-dbk-ekd

tun26111905

www.tuenews.de/en